Wondering Wings

I often use Butterflies and Moths of North America (BAMONA) as a resource when identifying butterflies in my garden or learning about what particular butterflies might require by way of food sources, but I’ve never utilized the  site’s submission process to ID an unknown butterfly or moth.  Instead, I comb through lists of photos from various sites, comparing whatever photo I took with shots from these sites.  While not efficient, there’s something gratifying about this process.  For me, it’s much like strolling through a bookstore or library, perhaps with one book in mind, but gloriously distracted by volumes just begging to be read. Or, visiting a nursery for a specific plant and lusting after the many I might  choose for that one special spot in the garden.

While Butterflies and Moths of North America is a go-to site for me in learning about these insects, I’ve never submitted a photo for identification. Recently though, my enterprising husband did, and we learned about a new (to us) insect in our midst.  Ambling around our street to give our sweet, old dog some exercise, we spied a black and fast-flitting insect working a neighbor’s Wooly Butterfly BushBuddleja marrubiifolia, (which is a plant I would LOVE to grow, but, alas, don’t quite have the full sun required).  The winged thing was swift and jittery in its flight pattern, moving rapidly from bloom to leaf and back to bloom again.  It was tough to get a clear photo with The Hub’s cell phone.


This is not a great shot, but is enough to decipher markings and color.

Once home, The Husband was single-minded in his pursuit of butterfly truth, perusing photos from various sites, eventually landing on the BAMONA site for identifying this mystery critter.  He noticed that BAMONA allows for submission of photos for butterfly/moth identification, so he got right to that task.  To  submit a photo for identification, the site requires a free account, but that’s super easy–Hub signed up for an account and you can too!  In the ‘Get Involved’ section of the menu bar, the drop down menu lists ‘Submit a Photo’ and in that section are general instructions for creating a sighting record, with further information about photo downloads to the BAMONA staff.  Almost immediately after his submission, The Husband received a confirmation email that his submission was accepted, with assurances that he would get a follow-up email.  The next morning, he received that email confirmation of what we observed: our mystery critter was a moth, a White-tipped Black, Melanchroia chephise. The regional coordinator offered a link to BAMONA’s information on this moth, as well as a link to The Hub’s submission, Sighting Record 1108573.   Woot!  It’s cool to be part of the scientific process!

Not long afterward during  an early morning walk with my furry, four-legged friend, I picked up from the street a (probably) dying White-tipped Black.




I brought it home and placed it on a Wild ruellia leaf.  It remained there for much of that day, but  eventually disappeared to unknown parts.


When we first saw this species on the neighbor’s plant, I congratulated myself because I thought that it might be a moth. I’m reasonably familiar with butterflies in this area and didn’t recognize it, but I’m not so familiar with moths, as they’re more elusive and not necessarily out when I’m out.

One moth characteristic is of fuzzy, feathery antennae, rather than the slender antennae typical of butterflies, and you can clearly see that here:


I was pleased that The Hub’s initiative provided a correct identification of this lovely moth. Many scientific organizations encourage and rely on so-called “citizen scientists” as scientific eyes on the ground,  helping these organizations ascertain wildlife migration patterns and changing demographics. After all, wildlife biologists and related professionals can’t be everywhere!  They welcome avid gardeners and regular folk to assist in research, education and conservation of wildlife and native habitats through controlled observations and recordings.  My own volunteer work with Cornell Lab of Ornithology is another example of a scientific educational and research organization which enjoys plenty of citizen input.

Another butterfly resource is the National Butterfly Center, located in Mission, Texas.   Part of the North American Butterfly Association, the organization’s mission is research and conservation of butterflies and their required habitats.  Along with the other great work this organization does, they sponsor an annual photo contest, the North American Butterfly Photo Contest.  (I’ll bet they also include moths, too!)  This past week, Julie Shaw of Austin was announced as the winner with her ‘Juniper Hairstreak on Milkweed’ photo. Congratulations, Julie, and wow–what a photo!

Fact-based, non-profit organizations like the three mentioned in this post are always in need of support and volunteers;  please consider monetary donations (end of tax year!) to the myriad scientific (and social) organizations whose dedicated professional staff and volunteers work tirelessly to achieve education and/or conservation goals.  In post-truth America, where cynical, dangerous assaults on science, nature, and personal freedoms abound, it is increasingly important to counter falsehoods and misrepresentations with facts, reason, funds, and boots-on-the-ground activity.


17 thoughts on “Wondering Wings

  1. And don’t forget BugGuide! I finally got brave enough to submit a katydid photo to them, and within ten minutes had a good ID of a meadow katydid nymph. They have a section on butterflies, too, of course. I found an insect on my trip that looks for all the world like a horse ready to be saddled. I need to get that one identified, too, before I share it.

    I’m glad to have these butterfly resources, which I didn’t know about. Last Thursday at work, I noticed a very small white butterfly with black wing edges fluttering through. It was quite striking, and I resolved to try and identify it. I haven’t yet, but now I will.


    • I never forget about BugGuide.net! It’s also an excellent resource, as you point out. Both organizations, as well as others, make it relatively simple to learn about the critters in our midst. Or, are we the critters in their midst?


  2. Tina the chephise moth Melanchroia is beautiful. I am so glad that she is so involved in the conservation of butterflies, moths and insects. And that has the support of sites like The Hub where sending a photo answer you identifying the species. I do not know if in Spain there are similar sites: I have not looked for them, but I have haformación and gacer. It is a wonderful post, full of innas to participate in the cause. Thank you Tina. Greetings from Margarita.


    • Thanks, Margarita. I know in the UK there are organizations which encourage citizens to participate with scientific studies and observations. I’ll bet there are similar organizations in Spain, too.


      • Thank you, Tina. Surely in Spain there are also such organizations. But now with the Christmas Festivities that are coming and the doctors of my Fathers I have no time to look for them. As soon as I have a gap, I’ll get to it. Greetings from Margarita.


  3. That is a good site to know about. I have asked for ids on Bug Guide too but this one is more specific. this year was such a big year for butterflies so I bought myself one of the Texas cards.The white-tipped black was not on it. I think I will be able to remember this one if I see one next year.


    • I like BugGuide, but it is nice to utilize a site that is specific, as you say. You’d immediately notice this moth, the black is so stunning against blooms and foliage.


  4. I use the BAMONA site, too. Partly for ID, but also to learn about host plants, habitats, and other information. My favorite site for ID is wisconsinbutterflies.org. Of course, it’s dedicated to butterflies in my state, but many of them can be found throughout eastern and central North America. Cool that you found this moth. It is beautiful!


    • I’m not the least bit surprised that BAMONA is a go-to site for you, Beth. It’s great that you have a specific to Wisconsin butterfly site. There are a couple here in Texas, but I find they concentrate on South Texas quite a bit. I also thought the moth was just gorgeous!


  5. That’s a beautiful creature, especially the colors and antennae. I think citizen science is super important … not just for data collection but also to build up interest in and support for nature. I’ve been working on an iNaturalist project (plants) for awhile but unfortunately I was a slacker this year. Next summer should be better–officially old enough to retire now.


    • It is beautiful, I agree. Yes, I think the scientific community, especially the organizations which promote nature and our responsibilities toward it, are wise to include citizens. It’s great that you’re involved with iNaturalist and even better that retirement is on the horizon–you know, so that you can hang out with the things you love, rocks and plants. 🙂


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s